NewEnergyNews: PROF DISSES EROEI STATS/

NewEnergyNews

Gleanings from the web and the world, condensed for convenience, illustrated for enlightenment, arranged for impact...

The challenge now: To make every day Earth Day.

YESTERDAY

THINGS-TO-THINK-ABOUT WEDNESDAY, August 23:

  • TTTA Wednesday-ORIGINAL REPORTING: The IRA And The New Energy Boom
  • TTTA Wednesday-ORIGINAL REPORTING: The IRA And the EV Revolution
  • THE DAY BEFORE

  • Weekend Video: Coming Ocean Current Collapse Could Up Climate Crisis
  • Weekend Video: Impacts Of The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Current Collapse
  • Weekend Video: More Facts On The AMOC
  • THE DAY BEFORE THE DAY BEFORE

    WEEKEND VIDEOS, July 15-16:

  • Weekend Video: The Truth About China And The Climate Crisis
  • Weekend Video: Florida Insurance At The Climate Crisis Storm’s Eye
  • Weekend Video: The 9-1-1 On Rooftop Solar
  • THE DAY BEFORE THAT

    WEEKEND VIDEOS, July 8-9:

  • Weekend Video: Bill Nye Science Guy On The Climate Crisis
  • Weekend Video: The Changes Causing The Crisis
  • Weekend Video: A “Massive Global Solar Boom” Now
  • THE LAST DAY UP HERE

    WEEKEND VIDEOS, July 1-2:

  • The Global New Energy Boom Accelerates
  • Ukraine Faces The Climate Crisis While Fighting To Survive
  • Texas Heat And Politics Of Denial
  • --------------------------

    --------------------------

    Founding Editor Herman K. Trabish

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    WEEKEND VIDEOS, June 17-18

  • Fixing The Power System
  • The Energy Storage Solution
  • New Energy Equity With Community Solar
  • Weekend Video: The Way Wind Can Help Win Wars
  • Weekend Video: New Support For Hydropower
  • Some details about NewEnergyNews and the man behind the curtain: Herman K. Trabish, Agua Dulce, CA., Doctor with my hands, Writer with my head, Student of New Energy and Human Experience with my heart

    email: herman@NewEnergyNews.net

    -------------------

    -------------------

      A tip of the NewEnergyNews cap to Phillip Garcia for crucial assistance in the design implementation of this site. Thanks, Phillip.

    -------------------

    Pay a visit to the HARRY BOYKOFF page at Basketball Reference, sponsored by NewEnergyNews and Oil In Their Blood.

  • ---------------
  • WEEKEND VIDEOS, August 24-26:
  • Happy One-Year Birthday, Inflation Reduction Act
  • The Virtual Power Plant Boom, Part 1
  • The Virtual Power Plant Boom, Part 2

    Thursday, August 09, 2007

    PROF DISSES EROEI STATS

    NewEnergyNews is Jack-of-all-energies and Master-of-no-statistics but this guy’s vehemence is misplaced. Net Energy (aka EROEI and EROI, according to Robert Rapier, though others distinguish between the acronyms) is a very useful tool, though it may not be the tool for every job.

    The delicious contentiousness on this issue is reminiscent of the 1980s resistance of traditional baseball statisticians to the Sabremetrics Bill James was then brilliantly inventing. Now everybody knows that runs produced, slugging percentage and on-base percentage are more important stats than a mere home run number.

    There is more money in energy than baseball, so it will no doubt take the energy world longer to come around than it did baseball.


    Net energy – a useless, misleading and dangerous metric, says expert
    Jennifer Beal, 8 August 2007 (EurekAlert)

    WHO
    Professor Bruce Dale, Michigan State University

    Graphic explanation of EROEI, or Net Energy. (click to enlarge)

    WHAT
    Professor Dale argues that Net Energy (aka EROI and EROEI) is “dead wrong… dangerously misleading and must be removed” from the discourse on energy choices.

    WHEN
    This is part of an ongoing search for ways of assessing an evolving New Energy future.

    There is a website. (click to enlarge)

    WHERE
    Dale’s views were published in the 1st edition of Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining.

    WHY
    - Sample EROI analysis by Cutler Cleveland: Ten Fundamental Principles of Net Energy
    - Net Energy is a metric by which forms of energy can be compared. There are other metrics.
    - With oil prices rising and oil supplies failing to meet demands, it is useful to be able to evaluate other sources of energy.
    - Dale’s complaint about net energy is that it assumes all sources of energy have equal value but markets clearly value gas, petrol and electricity much more than coal. Dale believes it would be better to calculate how much petroleum an energy would displace or how much emission it generated.
    - Dale calculations: 1 MJ of ethanol displaces 28 MJ of petroleum; corn ethanol cuts emissions 18% from petroleum; cellulosic ethanol cuts emissions 88% from petroleum.
    - Energy authority Robert Rapier: “The EROEI, (Energy Returned on Energy Invested), EROI, and energy return all refer to the same idea. It is the ratio of usable energy returned from a process divided by the energy expended (consumed) in the production process. Or, simply put, if I expend a total of 1 BTU of energy in a process that yields 5 BTUs of energy, the EROEI is 5/1…This is an area rife with misunderstand and garbled definitions. Depending on where the system boundaries are drawn, one can come up with very different definitions…”

    The Net Energy calculation proving wind energy's viability. (click to enlarge)

    QUOTES
    - Rapier: “In reality, EROEI is a part of the overall evaluation, but by itself does not tell you much…Consider that your goal is merely to make money. You may be able to make lots of money with a process having an EROEI of less than 1. You can take a pound of BTU of coal and use it in an ethanol process to make less than a BTU of ethanol. Considering only your energy inputs, you have increased the value of your BTUs by a factor of 10. So, even if you take 1 BTU of coal and convert that into 0.7 BTUs of ethanol, there may be plenty of economic incentive to do it, despite the energy returns…EROEI matters. Sometimes. And as a part of the overall context.”
    - Dale: “Clear thinking shows that we value the services that energy can perform, not the energy per se, so it would be better to compare fuels by the services that each provides…not on a straight energy basis…which is likely to be irrelevant and misleading…”

    0 Comments:

    Post a Comment

    << Home