NewEnergyNews: ORIGINAL REPORTING, April 2: ACTIVISTS PUSH FOR NEW RTO AS SOUTHEAST UTILITY RESERVE MARGINS CALLED INTO QUESTION

NewEnergyNews

Gleanings from the web and the world, condensed for convenience, illustrated for enlightenment, arranged for impact...

December 7, 1941: Time to forgive but not forget.

The challenge now: To make every day Earth Day.

YESTERDAY

  • TODAY’S STUDY: How To Balance Competing Solar Interests
  • QUICK NEWS, December 6: Sliver Of Hope? Al Gore In Climate Change Meet With Donald Trump; The Opportunity In New Energy; Google Seizing New Energy Opportunity
  • THE DAY BEFORE

  • TODAY’S STUDY: A Way For New Energy To Meet Peak Demand
  • QUICK NEWS, December 5: Trial Of The Century Coming On Climate; The Wind-Solar Synergy; The Still Rising Sales Of Cars With Plugs
  • THE DAY BEFORE THE DAY BEFORE

  • Weekend Video: Trump Truth And Climate Change
  • Weekend Video: The Daily Show Talks Pipeline Politics
  • Weekend Video: Beyond Polar Bears – The Real Science Of Climate Change
  • THE DAY BEFORE THAT

  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-Aussie Farmers Worrying About Climate Change
  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-The Climate Change Solution At Hand, Part 1
  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-The Climate Change Solution At Hand, Part 2
  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-New Energy And Historic Buildings In Europe
  • AND THE DAY BEFORE THAT

    THINGS-TO-THINK-ABOUT THURSDAY, December 1:

  • TTTA Thursday-First Daughter Ivanka May Fight For Climate
  • TTTA Thursday-Low Profile High Power Ocean Wind Energy
  • TTTA Thursday-A Visionary Solar Power Plant
  • TTTA Thursday-EVs Have A Growth Path
  • THE LAST DAY UP HERE

  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: How The Clean Power Plan Drove The Utility Power Mix Transition
  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: How Utilities Are Answering The Distributed Energy Resources Challenge
  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: Looking At New Rates To Unlock The Utility Of The Future
  • --------------------------

    --------------------------

    Anne B. Butterfield of Daily Camera and Huffington Post, f is an occasional contributor to NewEnergyNews

    -------------------

    Some of Anne's contributions:

  • Another Tipping Point: US Coal Supply Decline So Real Even West Virginia Concurs (REPORT), November 26, 2013
  • SOLAR FOR ME BUT NOT FOR THEE ~ Xcel's Push to Undermine Rooftop Solar, September 20, 2013
  • NEW BILLS AND NEW BIRDS in Colorado's recent session, May 20, 2013
  • Lies, damned lies and politicians (October 8, 2012)
  • Colorado's Elegant Solution to Fracking (April 23, 2012)
  • Shale Gas: From Geologic Bubble to Economic Bubble (March 15, 2012)
  • Taken for granted no more (February 5, 2012)
  • The Republican clown car circus (January 6, 2012)
  • Twenty-Somethings of Colorado With Skin in the Game (November 22, 2011)
  • Occupy, Xcel, and the Mother of All Cliffs (October 31, 2011)
  • Boulder Can Own Its Power With Distributed Generation (June 7, 2011)
  • The Plunging Cost of Renewables and Boulder's Energy Future (April 19, 2011)
  • Paddling Down the River Denial (January 12, 2011)
  • The Fox (News) That Jumped the Shark (December 16, 2010)
  • Click here for an archive of Butterfield columns

    -------------------

    Some details about NewEnergyNews and the man behind the curtain: Herman K. Trabish, Agua Dulce, CA., Doctor with my hands, Writer with my head, Student of New Energy and Human Experience with my heart

    email: herman@NewEnergyNews.net

    -------------------

    -------------------

      A tip of the NewEnergyNews cap to Phillip Garcia for crucial assistance in the design implementation of this site. Thanks, Phillip.

    -------------------

    Pay a visit to the HARRY BOYKOFF page at Basketball Reference, sponsored by NewEnergyNews and Oil In Their Blood.

  • ---------------
  • TODAY AT NewEnergyNews, December 7:

  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: Turning Distributed Energy From Threat To Opportunity
  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: Solar Policy Action Heats Up
  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: Maine’s Almost Solar Policy Breakthrough

    Thursday, April 02, 2015

    ORIGINAL REPORTING, April 2: ACTIVISTS PUSH FOR NEW RTO AS SOUTHEAST UTILITY RESERVE MARGINS CALLED INTO QUESTION

    The regular Things-To-Think-About-Thursday feature will return next week.

    Activists push for new RTO as Southeast utility reserve margins called into question; NC WARN says Duke, Southern and others are gouging ratepayers for billions, blocking renewables

    Herman K. Trabish, January 6, 2015 (Utility Dive)

    The state-by-state fight between utilities and renewables advocates just went national. A North Carolina group has asked federal regulators to investigate Duke Energy, the Southern Company, and other big Southeastern utilities for possible power price manipulations it says boost utility profits and block renewables and efficiency from the market.

    NC WARN wants the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to calculate “how many billions are being wasted across the Southeast” due to the overbuilding of generation facilities, and to push seven southeastern states for data that would show “how much could be saved annually if utilities begin sharing power supply through regional cooperation.”

    The charge is that southeastern utilities have built over twice the 14% to 15% reserve power generation capacity they need to meet peak demand. U.S. Energy Information Administration data shows they maintain reserve margins between 24% and 37%, NC WARN charged.

    By convincing state regulators to approve new nuclear and fossil generation, NC WARN explained in its petition to FERC, the utilities have imposed higher rates on their customers.

    “Electricity users in Florida, Georgia, and South Carolina have suffered up to six rate hikes for nuclear plant construction projects that have either failed or are experiencing delays and cost overruns,” NC WARN reported.

    By owning more than ample excess generation, utilities keep electricity supply high. That drives electricity rates lower, below the break-even point for new resources like wind or solar. In effect, NC WARN argues, southeastern utilities are building more fossil fuel generation so they can price renewables out of the market. Even with recent rate increases, electricity prices remain lowest in southeastern states, where much of the generation still comes from coal and nuclear. At the same time, southeastern utilities rank near or at the bottom in renewable energy integration.

    Duke Energy insists it has removed old coal capacity while adding new, cleaner generation sources like natural gas facilities and utility-scale solar arrays. NC WARN says the net change has increased Duke’s reserves.

    Reserve capacity and load growth

    While the North American Reliability Council (NERC) standard for reserve capacity is around 15%, EIA’s summer 2014 forecast put the Carolinas’ unused generation capacity at 24%, Tennessee’s at 26%, Georgia’s and Alabama’s at 37%, and Florida’s at 29%.

    Duke Energy’s most recent 15-year Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) projects resource margins “in the 15% to 20% range,” explained Spokesperson Randy Wheeless. “We don’t think there is an overcapacity.”

    Those reserve margins are based on projected overall electricity demand growth of 1.5%, net growth after energy efficiency impacts of 1.0%, and a 1.4% peak demand growth.

    Because the EIA and the others forecast a flat or declining long-term growth in demand, NC WARN believes Duke’s estimate is high.

    “Adjusted for a reasonable demand growth rate of 0.5%,” NC WARN charged, Duke’s reserves would be “23% to 33% from 2020 to 2029.” Its peak demand reserve capacity during months of lower electricity consumption would be as high as 57%. Technologies ranging from LED lighting and efficient air conditioning to increasingly affordable solar and combined heat and power systems will keep electricity demand from rising, according to former FERC Chair Jon Wellinghoff.

    “There will be virtually no load growth at the grid level for the foreseeable future,” he told Utility Dive.

    Without load growth, Wellinghoff said, it will take some time before big plants being approved by state regulators in southeastern states will be useful.

    A new RTO for the Southeast?

    A regional solution benefits ratepayers by eliminating the need to build new plants that drive rates up, explained NC WARN Counsel John Runkle.

    “A regional solution is a hedge against flat load growth because it gives you better access to markets and allows you to market the excess more efficiently and at better prices,” Wellinghoff explained.

    The regional solution NC WARN wants is a regional transmission organization (RTO) that creates a wholesale electricity market across the Southeast. Thriving RTOs such as the Midcontinent Independent System Operator (MISO), the PJM Interconnection, and the Southwest Power Pool (SPP) help deliver two-thirds of U.S. electricity.

    Many powerful, vertically integrated utilities and state regulators object to regional solutions because it means sacrificing some autonomy.

    Advocates of regional solutions say they provide utilities with more options and better options to keep the lights on than just building power plants. By creating markets, they also make electricity a commodity, make pricing transparent, and drive innovators to find more competitive resources.

    FERC established regulations for a regional solution in 1999 under the Federal Power Act (FPA). Minimum characteristics are that it must be (1) independent, (2) have a regional configuration, (3) have operational authority over participants, and (4) increase short-term reliability.

    An RTO must also (1) design and administer tariffs, (2) manage transmission congestion, (3) maintain power flow, (4) provide ancillary services, (5) haveOASIS-based transmission monitoring and management, (6) effectively monitor its market, (7) plan and expand its services, and (8) coordinate inter-regionally.

    The Entergy story: Bringing a big utility into an RTO

    As FERC chair, Wellinghoff acted on complaints against the Entergy companies in Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Texas by arranging to bring their 30 GW generating capacity and 2.8 million utility customers into MISO.

    “The problems with Entergy had gone on for a long time and state jurisdictions were ready and willing to sit down and consider alternatives,” Wellinghoff recalled. He was able to arrange a workshop in which Entergy executives and experts testified before representatives of the state regulatory agencies.

    From the workshop, evidence emerged that MISO participation would benefit Entergy customers. It convinced state regulators to go forward with a FERC-funded study to quantify the costs and benefits. When the analysis showed a $1.6 billion net benefit, state commissions in the Entergy states chose economic development and keeping total costs down over the loss of jurisdictional authority, Wellinghoff explained.

    Wellinghoff said a similar approach might work with utilities in the southeastern states. “If I was the FERC Chair now, I would see if the states are willing to consider alternatives.”

    A summit in the offing?

    Duke Energy has shown willingness to work with stakeholders, Wheeless said. He cited Duke’s participation in the compromise that produced South Carolina’s landmark solar law. “We got a lot of parties who don’t normally agree on very much to agree on something very big,” he said.

    Duke would likely participate in a similar summit to consider a regional electricity market solution, Wheeless said, if there was “regulatory momentum” for it. But, he noted, the 2012 merger of Duke and Progress was almost derailed by rumors FERC would require the utilities to join an RTO.

    “All sides knew such a requirement would certainly be rejected by state regulators, which would have to give up significant regulatory authority to FERC,” the Charlotte Business Journal reported at the time.

    Interestingly, new transmission required by FERC to mitigate concerns about the merger’s effect on market competition have already produced some $300 million in cumulative savings for North Carolina and South Carolina customers, Duke recently reported. The combined operations of the two utilities’ generation fleets have the merged entity “on track to meet the $687 million in cumulative customer savings it guaranteed to regulators during the first five years after the merger.”

    When asked if this suggested larger potential savings from participating in a regional solution, Wheeless said only that some Duke subsidiaries do operate in states with RTOs but it isn’t clear there is interest for one in the Southeast.

    Both Runkle and Wheeless said Duke will have a formal response to the NC WARN filing with FERC by mid-January.

    0 Comments:

    Post a Comment

    << Home

  • >