NewEnergyNews: TODAY’S STUDY: Why The U.S. Needs A Western Energy Market

NewEnergyNews

Gleanings from the web and the world, condensed for convenience, illustrated for enlightenment, arranged for impact...

While the OFFICE of President remains in highest regard at NewEnergyNews, this administration's position on climate change makes it impossible to regard THIS president with respect. Below is the NewEnergyNews theme song until 2020.

The challenge now: To make every day Earth Day.

YESTERDAY

  • TODAY’S STUDY: How The New Energy Marketplace Is Growing And Shifting
  • QUICK NEWS, December 11: N.C. Millennial Women Unite For Climate Fight; The White House Threat To New Energy; What’s Bad News In The Tax Bill For New Energy
  • THE DAY BEFORE

  • Weekend Video: Tesla Adds World’s Biggest Battery To Aussie Wind
  • Weekend Video: Solar And The Next Utilities
  • Weekend Video: Wind Builders On Wind
  • THE DAY BEFORE THE DAY BEFORE

  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-The Climate Change Gourmet
  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-UK Study Says Yes To Solar-Powered Electric Trains
  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-First Aussie Ocean Wind Project Gets $8BIL Funding
  • FRIDAY WORLD HEADLINE-EU Solar Goes Digital To Open New Services
  • THE DAY BEFORE THAT

    THINGS-TO-THINK-ABOUT THURSDAY, December 7:

  • TTTA Thursday-City Mayors Unite To Fight Climate Change
  • TTTA Thursday-New Energy And Big Oil Unite Against Subsidies For Coal And Nuclear
  • TTTA Thursday-California Would Sell Only EVs After 2040
  • TTTA Thursday-Utilities In A Time Of Solar
  • THE LAST DAY UP HERE

  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: California Grid Users Collaborate to Streamline Communication Systems
  • ORIGINAL REPORTING: How To Get The Big Benefits Of Grid-Integrated Water Heaters
  • --------------------------

    --------------------------

    Founding Editor Herman K. Trabish

    --------------------------

    --------------------------

    Some details about NewEnergyNews and the man behind the curtain: Herman K. Trabish, Agua Dulce, CA., Doctor with my hands, Writer with my head, Student of New Energy and Human Experience with my heart

    email: herman@NewEnergyNews.net

    -------------------

    -------------------

      A tip of the NewEnergyNews cap to Phillip Garcia for crucial assistance in the design implementation of this site. Thanks, Phillip.

    -------------------

    Pay a visit to the HARRY BOYKOFF page at Basketball Reference, sponsored by NewEnergyNews and Oil In Their Blood.

  • ---------------
  • TODAY AT NewEnergyNews, December 12:

  • TODAY’S STUDY: The Value Of Transportation Elecrification
  • QUICK NEWS, December 12: The “Fight-Climate-Change” Diet; Market For Advanced EV Batteries To Quadruple By 2026; The Low Lifecycle Costs In New Energy

    Monday, June 19, 2017

    TODAY’S STUDY: Why The U.S. Needs A Western Energy Market

    Enhanced Western Grid Integration: A Legal and Policy Analysis of the Effects on California’s Clean Energy Laws

    Juliana Brint, Josh Constanti, Franz Hochstrasser, and Lucy Kessler, May 2017 (Yale Law School and Yale School of Forestry & Environmental Studies)

    Executive Summary

    This analysis addresses the legal and policy merits of a transition to a fully integrated electricity grid in the Western United States through the creation of a regional independent system operator. We summarize the increasing constraints that today’s balkanized grid imposes on system-wide electricity costs and reliability, address the potential benefits of enhanced grid integration, and evaluate potential legal risks for key California clean energy policies.

    Wind and solar power are the dominant sources of new renewable energy in the United States and can provide numerous benefits to the economy and the environment. However, the variable nature of these technologies can create grid integration challenges for electricity system operators in some circumstances because renewable energy supply does not necessarily track demand. As California increases its renewable energy generation, it often has to curtail or shut down clean energy that is produced when demand is low. In February 2017, the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) warned that it may need to curtail 6,000 megawatts (MW) to 8,000 MW of renewable energy capacity during some hours in the spring of 2017,1 which is equivalent to 60 to 80% of the total installed large-scale solar generating capacity in the CAISO.2 This means that CAISO will not be able to take full advantage of this inexpensive and pollution-free generation. One way to improve grid reliability, minimize curtailments, and reduce the variability of renewable energy is to create a regional independent system operator to balance supply and demand across a larger geographic area.

    Within the Western grid (known as the “Western Interconnection”), electricity is managed by 38 separate balancing authorities (BA) across the United States, Canada, and Mexico. All 38 BAs, including CAISO, are part of the synchronized Western Interconnection but each BA is independently responsible for balancing supply and demand in its own territory. In order to improve reliability, cut costs, and increase efficiency, a number of these balancing authorities are partnering in the Western energy imbalance market (EIM), which is managed by CAISO. The EIM is a “real-time market” that adjusts for forecast errors between supply and demand every five minutes. This regional market has demonstrated numerous benefits of enhanced regional grid integration, such as reducing costs and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. However, the EIM is limited in that it only allows for incremental adjustments to generation dispatch schedules and only captures a small portion of the region’s wholesale electricity market. CAISO, Western states, and other stakeholders throughout the West are exploring the creation of a more fully integrated regional electricity market that would be comprehensively managed by a single system operator and include a day-ahead market and other benefits. Such a market could enhance utilities’ resource planning, improve grid efficiency and reliability, and save utility customers money while meeting the West’s demand for reliable, affordable, and clean electricity.

    This report examines the potential impacts of an integrated Western electricity market on California’s clean energy policies, including the state’s renewable portfolio standard (RPS), the greenhouse gas emissions performance standard (EPS) for long-term contracts with baseload power plants, and the cap-and-trade program established by AB 32, the state’s groundbreaking climate law. We find that enhanced Western grid integration—through the creation of a regional ISO—does not interfere with these clean energy policies, and it instead can assist California in meeting its objectives by creating more market opportunities for renewable energy, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and other pollution, and improving the transmission system’s efficiency and reliability. CAISO is not now, and would not become a policy-making body, but like other multi-state grid operators it would assist the states it serves in achieving their own policy objectives at lower cost while improving electric system reliability.

    While California’s clean energy policies could be the subject of future legal challenges, the likelihood and prospects of such challenges would not be affected by enhanced Western grid integration.

    Two provisions of the U.S. Constitution pose theoretical threats to California’s clean energy laws: the Supremacy Clause3 and the Commerce Clause.4 Under the Supremacy Clause, a state law is preempted and invalid if it conflicts with a federal law,5 such as the Federal Power Act (FPA) or the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA). Additionally, the “dormant” Commerce Clause imposes limits on state actions that discriminate against out-of-state commerce,6 unduly burden interstate commerce,7 or assert control over conduct that occurs outside the state’s borders.8 Opponents of regional grid integration might argue that the creation of a regional power market could call the legality of California’s clean energy laws into question under either of these two provisions.

    Our analysis indicates that the expansion of CAISO into a regional system operator across several states would not make these challenges any more likely to succeed.9 Given the highly interconnected nature of the electric grid in the Western United States through the Western Interconnection, wholesale sales and transmission of electricity in the CAISO footprint are already treated as forms of “interstate commerce”10 subject to regulation by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) under the FPA. California laws and regulations affecting wholesale electricity transactions could be subject to challenges today if they conflict with federal energy law, and those same laws and regulations are already subject to scrutiny under the dormant Commerce Clause. As long as California and other Western states remain within the Western Interconnection, the potential for Supremacy Clause and dormant Commerce Clause challenges will not change. It is noteworthy that to date there have been no such challenges.

    In sum, enhanced Western grid integration under a regional system operator would not expose California’s clean energy policies to additional risks of preemption under the FPA or challenges based on the dormant Commerce Clause. Shifting to a regional grid operator would enable more efficient, affordable, and reliable integration of renewable resources without increasing the legal risk to California’s clean energy policies.

    IFTTT Recipe: Share new blog posts to Facebook connects blogger to facebook

    0 Comments:

    Post a Comment

    << Home